[governance] IGC members list

[Parminder]

Adam

> Parminder, Hi, this is very interesting.
> 
> However, could you please draw up a ballot.

I draw your attention to my email of 15th. To quote my email

"I have every intention to uphold the charter, in the best possible manner,
in the matter of voting process as well, reconciling any apparent
contradiction as they may appear to different people. My proposal for this
will be presented after the 17th when this round of membership list building
will be completed."

I also said

"I am not intervening is this discussion on_the_issue_of_the_voting_process
because, as I mentioned in an earlier email, some of these discussions have
been confusing list participants a lot in terms of the primary task being
done at this stage which is to prepare a members list as per the charter."

So can you please just wait for my proposal on this and trust my word that I
will "uphold the charter in the best possible manner". 

And it is not that in the meantime I am not doing some important caucus
work. For you drawing up the members list as per the charter conditions may
be merely 'very interesting' but I think it is a central organizational
activity for the caucus. And it is not an easy task to keep track of all the
emails I receive from around 120 members, seeking clarification, clarifying
issues, building an appropriate list, opening it for comments before
finalization etc. And I am doing all this as I am traveling. 

>>I will keep this list open for 2 more days, for anyone to comment on 
>>his or her exclusion or inclusion.

>No, that's not your decision.  

What is not my decision? To keep a list open to corrections etc before
announcing it as the standing IGC members list on the day?? How/ Why?
And you would of course have read the next sentence in my email " The list,
however, remains open for inclusion of new members at all times."

> Please read the charter and follow what it instructs you to do.

Thanks for your advice. I do read the charter often. 

I also requested in my mail

" For many reasons that I have argued a few times earlier, and will mention
again in my email after the 17th, it will help us greatly at this stage if
we see these two issues 'separately' - (1) the issue of preparing a members
list as per the charter and (2) voting process for electing a new
co-coordinator, also as per the charter."

You have the complete right to post whatever you wish anytime to the list
but I must observe that this present email too does add to the confusion at
the stage when some members are still in the process of confirming IGC
membership, which I had requested to avoid.

Meanwhile, I must also remind you that you had advised me to make a members
list in your email dated 23rd April which I quote.

"If someone has been subscribed to the list for two months they should be
sent an email asking them if they wish to become a member of the caucus and
if they subscribe to the IGC charter (which means they have read the charter
<http://www.igcaucus.org/IGC-charter_final-061014.html > and accept the
provisions of the charter.)  If they answer yes, they are members and can be
added to a member list." (Adam)


Parminder  















> -----Original Message-----
> From: Adam Peake [mailto:ajp at glocom.ac.jp]
> Sent: Sunday, July 20, 2008 9:51 PM
> To: governance at lists.cpsr.org; Parminder
> Subject: Re: [governance] IGC members list
> 
> >Hi All
> >
> >Enclosed is a list of 114 IGC members who have
> >accepted membership of the caucus as per the
> >charter¹s condition, i.e. subscription to the
> >charter.
> 
> 
> Parminder, Hi, this is very interesting.
> 
> However, could you please draw up a ballot.
> Arrange for the ballot to be sent to all who have
> been subscribed to the list for at least two
> months (have you set a cut-off date for this, or
> does it roll on and on?) Include on the ballot a
> question asking the person to confirm they are a
> member of the IGC based on membership criteria as
> described in the charter
> <http://www.igcaucus.org/IGC-charter_final-061014.html>.
> Relevant sections of the charter:
> 
> Voting Process
> 
> Each person who is subscribed to the list at
> least two (2) months before the election will be
> given a voter account.
> 
> As part of the voting process the voter must
> personally ascertain that they are a member of
> the IGC based on membership criteria described
> elsewhere in this charter and posted as part of
> the voting information (i.e. a voter must affirm
> membership on the voter form in order to vote).
> The decision to self-identify as a member of the
> IGC is a personal decision based on the criteria
> defined. A list of the self-defined member-voters
> will be published after the election with the
> results of the election.
> and,
> 
> Membership
> 
> The members of the IGC are individuals, acting in
> personal capacity, who subscribe to the charter
> of the caucus. All members are equal and have the
> same rights and duties.
> 
> 
> >To quote the charter Œthe members of the IGC are
> >individuals, acting in personal capacity, who
> >subscribe to the charter of the caucus¹.
> >
> >I will keep this list open for 2 more days, for
> >anyone to comment on his or her exclusion or
> >inclusion.
> 
> 
> No, that's not your decision.  Please read the
> charter and follow what it instructs you to do.
> You should send the ballot to all who have been
> subscribed to the list at least two (2) months
> before the election.
> 
> Note that a list self-defined member-voters will
> be published after the election.
> 
> Thanks,
> 
> Adam
> 
> 
> 
> >After that, the list will be posted as the
> >current IGC members list. The list, however,
> >remains open for inclusion of new members at all
> >times.
> >
> >It is quite a task to keep track of all the
> >emails from the members, and consequently there
> >could be inaccuracies in the list which please
> >point out. I may especially have inadvertently
> >missed including someone¹s name even after a
> >confirmation email was sent to me. Please look
> >your name up in the list and inform me about any
> >such mistake.
> >
> >I am also taking the liberty to include the
> >names of three members regarding whom there is
> >enough indication that they do subscribe to the
> >charter but who, apparently, to my best
> >understanding, did not respond to my email due
> >to difference in our understanding of some
> >technical issues regarding IGC processes. I will
> >include the names of Avri, McTim and Jeanette to
> >this list before I put it out finally in 2 days.
> >To do so was also suggested by Tapani on the
> >list, to which suggestion I agree.
> >
> >I will also add to this list more information
> >about those members who have volunteered
> >additional information.
> >
> >
> >Parminder
> >
> >
> >CS ­ IGC Members List as of 18 July 2008 (tentative)
> >
> >
> >
> >1
> >Rabia Abdelkrim Chikh
> >2
> >Veronica Cretu
> >3
> >Philippe Goujon
> >4
> >Rudi Vansnick
> >5
> >Ralf Bendrath
> >6
> >Erick Iriarte Ahon
> >7
> >Karen Banks
> >8
> >Sheraan Amod
> >9
> >Tapani Tarvainen
> >10
> >Md. Hakikur Rahman
> >11
> >Jac SM Kee
> >12
> >Izumi Aizu
> >13
> >Francoise Massit-Follea
> >14
> >Dave Kissoondoyal
> >15
> >William Drake
> >16
> >Al Alegre
> >17
> >Mawaki Chango
> >18
> >Ahmed Swapan Mahmood
> >19
> >Max Senges
> >20
> >Abiodun Jagun
> >21
> >Kevin Choi
> >22
> >Ching Chiao
> >23
> >Sylvia Caras
> >24
> >Michael Gurstein
> >25
> >Hempal Shrestha
> >26
> >Hong Xue
> >27
> >Koven Ronald
> >28
> >Jeffrey A. Williams
> >29
> >Gao Mosweu
> >30
> >Nnenna Nwakanma
> >31
> >Iffat Rose Gill
> >32
> >Ian Peter
> >33
> >Jacqueline A. Morris
> >34
> >Tijani Ben Jemaa
> >35
> >Robert Guerra
> >36
> >Graciela Selaimen
> >37
> >Raquel Gatto
> >38
> >Divina Frau-Meigs
> >39
> >Schombe Baudouin
> >40
> >Wolfgang Benedek
> >41
> >Roshni Nuggehalli
> >42
> >Gurumurthy Kasinathan
> >43
> >Vivek Vaidyanathan
> >44
> >Lyman Chapin
> >45
> >Virginia (Ginger) Paque
> >46
> >Pablo Accuosto
> >47
> >Garth Graham
> >48
> >Danny Butt
> >49
> >Jeremy Malcolm
> >50
> >Josep Xercavins i Valls
> >51
> >David Allen
> >52
> >Hans Klein
> >53
> >Michael Froomkin
> >54
> >Janna Quitney Anderson
> >55
> >John Mathiason
> >56
> >Milton Mueller
> >57
> >Jeremy Hunsinger
> >58
> >Hanane Boujemi
> >59
> >Iliya Bazlyankov.
> >60
> >Vittorio Bertola
> >61
> >Patrick Vande Walle
> >62
> >Yuri Hohlov
> >63
> >Daniel Pimienta
> >64
> >Olugbenga Adeyemo
> >65
> >Carolina Aguerre
> >66
> >Ricardo Ruiz
> >67
> >Charles Mok
> >68
> >Fouad Bajwa
> >69
> >Siranush Vardanyan
> >70
> >Gbenga Sesan
> >71
> >Mr. Solomon Gizaw
> >72
> >Mr. Hartmut Glaser
> >73
> >Omar Kaminski
> >74
> >Matthias C. Kettemann
> >75
> >Magaly Pazello
> >76
> >Philip Napoli
> >77
> >Jacques Berleur
> >78
> >Wolfgang Kleinwaechter
> >79
> >William Currie
> >80
> >Anriette Esterhuysen
> >81
> >Robin Gross
> >82
> >Ken Lohento
> >83
> >Renate Bloem
> >84
> >Meryem Marzouki
> >85
> >Giacomo Mazzone
> >86
> >Lisa Horner
> >87
> >Carlton Samuels
> >88
> >Maja Andjelkovic
> >89
> >Nyangkwe Agien Aaron
> >90
> >Brenden Kuerbis
> >91
> >Shaila Mistry Rao
> >92
> >Bret Fausett
> >93
> >Adam Peake
> >94
> >Carlos Afonso
> >95
> >Raymond A Plzak
> >96
> >Lluis Miret
> >97
> >Derrick L. Cogburn
> >98
> >Lee McKnight
> >99
> >Anita Gurumurthy
> >100
> >Parminder Jeet Singh
> >101
> >David Goldstein
> >102
> >Jeremy Shtern
> >103
> >Shahzad Ahmad
> >104
> >Valeria Betancourt
> >105
> >Y J Park
> >106
> >Norbert Klein
> >107
> >Rudi Rusdiah
> >108
> >Daniel Oppermann
> >109
> >Yehuda Katz
> >110
> >Qusai AlShatti
> >111
> >Peter Hollings
> >112
> >Louis Pouzin
> >113
> >Tricia Wang
> >114
> >Sivasubramanian Muthusamy
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >Attachment converted: Macintosh HD:IGC members
> >list 180708.pdf (PDF /«IC») (005F44A8)
> >____________________________________________________________
> >You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
> >      governance at lists.cpsr.org
> >To be removed from the list, send any message to:
> >      governance-unsubscribe at lists.cpsr.org
> >
> >For all list information and functions, see:
> >      http://lists.cpsr.org/lists/info/governance
> 
> ____________________________________________________________
> You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
>      governance at lists.cpsr.org
> To be removed from the list, send any message to:
>      governance-unsubscribe at lists.cpsr.org
> 
> For all list information and functions, see:
>      http://lists.cpsr.org/lists/info/governance


____________________________________________________________
You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
     governance at lists.cpsr.org
To be removed from the list, send any message to:
     governance-unsubscribe at lists.cpsr.org

For all list information and functions, see:
     http://lists.cpsr.org/lists/info/governance