[governance] Reconstituting MAG

[Parminder]

> >>  7 from 46.
> >>
> >>  Adam
> >
> >
> >Thanks, Adam. We instinctively know you will correct us in such details,
> >which allow us to indulgence ourselves in not doing our homework. :)
> 
> 
> Oh don't trust me when maths in concerned... I was wrong. Seems there
> are 45 members!

It is strange but in our Feb and May 07 contributions we said that
"Moreover, we express our dissatisfaction with the very limited
representation of civil society in the first instance of the Advisory Group,
which amounted to about five members over about forty".

I now remember that's where I took the number 5 from.

Parminder 

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Adam Peake [mailto:ajp at glocom.ac.jp]
> Sent: Tuesday, February 19, 2008 3:02 PM
> To: Parminder; governance at lists.cpsr.org
> Cc: dogwallah at gmail.com
> Subject: RE: [governance] Reconstituting MAG
> 
> At 2:11 PM +0530 2/19/08, Parminder wrote:
> >  > 46 members (my count).  Plus 2 chairs (at the moment) and 12 special
> >>  advisers.
> >>
> >>  7 from 46.
> >>
> >>  Adam
> >
> >
> >Thanks, Adam. We instinctively know you will correct us in such details,
> >which allow us to indulgence ourselves in not doing our homework. :)
> 
> 
> Oh don't trust me when maths in concerned... I was wrong. Seems there
> are 45 members!
> 
> 
> >In fact I was just now thinking that the numbers of 11 or so of int orgs,
> 20
> >plus of gov and around 7 each of CS and PS just did not look right for a
> >total of 40.
> 
> 
> And distracted from work by McTim's Google docs, went over the list
> and believe the current MAG membership breaks down as follows:
> 
> Akinsanmi, Titilayo = CS
> Akplogan, Adiel = I*
> AlShatti, Qusai = CS
> Arida, Christine = GOV
> Bayramov, Ayaz = GOV
> Cavalli, Olga del Carmen = GOV
> Clarke, Trevor = GOV
> Daftardar, Abdullah M. = GOV
> Dardailler, Daniel = I*
> Diop Diagne, Ndeye Maimouna = GOV
> Disspain, Chris = I*
> Echeberria, Raul = I*
> Faltstrom, Patrik = I*
> Gadelha, Augusto Cesar Vieira = GOV
> Gallagher, Michael D.  = PS
> Graham, Bill = GOV
> Gross, Robin D.  = CS
> Hassan, Ayesha  = PS
> Hellmonds, Peter = PS
> Hofmann, Jeanette  = CS
> Iriarte, Erick  = CS
> Kafi, Abdullah  = PS
> Karklins, Janis  = GOV
> Katoh, Masanobu = PS
> Katundu, Michael = GOV
> Kisonas, Valdas  = GOV
> Khan, Masood = GOV
> Kovacs, Kalman = GOV
> Lohento, Gemma Brice (Ken) = CS
> Magalhaes, Luis = GOV
> Oliver, Colin = GOV
> Papadatos, George = GOV
> Peake, Adam = CS
> Pisanty, Alejandro = I*
> Quaynor, Nii = I*
> Sambrook, Richard = NO IDEA
> Sha'ban, Charles = PS
> Shanker, N. Ravi  = GOV
> Shears, Matthew = I*
> Swinehart, Theresa  = I*
> Tang, Zicai  = GOV
> Taylor, Emily  = I*
> Vasiliev, Vladimir  = GOV
> Yahaya, Issah = GOV
> Zangl, Peter = GOV
> 
> 
> I* is the various Internet organizations. I've based this on how I
> remember people associating themselves with different groups, or
> because it's obvious. It is the MAG as listed on the IGF website.
> 
> 45 members.  21 Government, 10 Internet organizations, 7 civil
> society and 6 private sector.  And 1 more is Richard Sambrook
> (representing the EBU I believe) I'm not know how to categorize him.
> EBU private sector?
> 
> McTim, don't agree with the way you've broken the groups down.  If
> you look at how people registered during WSIS you'll generally find
> the I* org registered as business (ICANN and APNIC I remember).  ISOC
> was civil society (and still is in GAID) as was W3C.  I think if you
> try to split the I* orgs they come out 7 private sector and 3 civil
> society.
> 
> Civil Society's under represented, that's the point we should be making.
> 
> Adam
> 
> 
> >Parminder
> >


____________________________________________________________
You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
     governance at lists.cpsr.org
To be removed from the list, send any message to:
     governance-unsubscribe at lists.cpsr.org

For all list information and functions, see:
     http://lists.cpsr.org/lists/info/governance