[governance] Internet Bill of Rights - Hoping there's progress .. wishing for it to succeed.

[Carlos Afonso]

I would suggest we take a look at the results of the Dialogue Forum on 
Internet Rights which will take place two days from now, besides the 
suggestions already made. Most of the doubts expressed so far here will 
certainly be considered there.

--c.a.

Vittorio Bertola wrote:
> Thanks, this is a valuable contribution.
> 
> Robert Guerra ha scritto:
>> first a question..is there a mailing list? If not, let me suggest one 
>> be created so that scholars and human rights professionals can come 
>> together to discuss , and develop a draft that's universal
> 
> Yes, there's a coalition website at 
> http://www.internet-bill-of-rights.org, a mailing list at
> http://mailman.ipjustice.org/listinfo/bill-of-rights, and also a 
> conference website at http://www.dfiritaly2007.it/ .
> 
>> In summary, one can't just announce someone as grand as an "internet 
>> bill of rights" and not engage others in a pro-active fashion. There 
>> is great interest in this - but, to succeed as a global inititiave  -  
>> it has to really be the work of an active international coalition  and 
>> not just one person or one country.
> 
> Sure, but someone has to start, and I think this is a problem for all 
> dynamic coalitions; at least in terms of mailing list messages, apart 
> from the Privacy one, the others seem to have activity levels that are 
> similar to or even less than that of the Bill of Rights DC.
> 
> Personally, I think that, more than at a monolithic Bill of Rights, we 
> should be aiming at a practical "Internet rights framework" developed at 
> the IGF, as the result of the coordinated work of all the coalitions. 
> There already are too manyv high level documents, and not enough 
> practical respect for human rights, or clarity about "down to earth" 
> principles that any blogger and any webmaster can apply. The BoR 
> coalition should thus discuss the conceptual and formal framework to get 
> to several declarations of rights, all deriving from the fundamental 
> statements of human rights, and all coming to a level which is clear, 
> applicable and enforceable.
> 
> On the other hand, this is for what I know the first attempt to a really 
> multistakeholder approach to this discussion. In the past, the techies 
> released their edicts, some NGOs did their own, and some governments 
> also did the same. What we need is to understand how to put all of this 
> together.


____________________________________________________________
You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
     governance at lists.cpsr.org
To be removed from the list, send any message to:
     governance-unsubscribe at lists.cpsr.org

For all list information and functions, see:
     http://lists.cpsr.org/lists/info/governance