[bestbits] Input into Brazil summit

[Andrew Puddephatt]

Hi everyone
Just to update you all.  So far the folk below on the chart have indicated a desire to collaborate to produce ideas to be submitted to the Brazil summit.  I've agreed to try and co-ordinate Stream 3, Matthew Shears has agreed to co-ordinate Stream 2 and Jeremy Malcolm Stream 1.  So thanks to them for stepping up.
Secondly I've received 20 responses to the survey monkey on Stream 3 IG governance - a couple of which were sent to me separately.  So thank you all for a fantastic response - it was really encouraging to read through all the ideas and observations people had.  I'm going to leave the survey open for a few days in case more ideas trickle in.
I thought the best step would be to circulate the raw survey material so you all get a chance to read the different responses - it's well worth spending an hour or two on them - lots of great ideas.
On reflection and discussing with the team here at GPD we thought the sensible next step was as follows.  Taking the submissions we have there are four steps we plan to take:

1.        Analysing and summarising what people say about the case for reform

2.       Developing a set of principles for the system of IG governance that would produce outcomes supportive of human rights and social justice (e.g. transparency, participation, inclusion, human rights promoting etc)

3.       Mapping/critiquing proposals for reform against these IG principles, grouping them if possible and setting out a risk/benefit analysis of the various ideas

4.       Putting together those combination of reform proposals that best fit the principles and submitting them for collective discussion.
I'd like to get your thoughts on this as a way forward.  We plan to undertake exercise at our end and send round our findings as soon as we can.  That will help define for us the areas of work that we'd be interested in pursuing.
Obviously we would welcome your thoughts on this approach. And once we produce the analysis, if you prefer to see what we come up with,  we'd welcome your contributions/suggestions/amendments etc.
Of course you may think there's a better way of handling the volume of material and you may just want to go off and draft your own proposals - the material is available for anyone to use however they want.  Everyone should free to take this forward how they wish.
Best

Andrew




Stream 1

Stream 2

Stream 3





Recommendation on process issues for the conference (remote participation, stakeholder representation and selection)

Substantive input on universal Internet principles (based on Marco Civil and/or other existing principles documents).

Substantive input on an institutional framework for multistakeholder Internet governance including: 1. Internationalisation of ICANN (based on existing work done by Internet Governance Project and/or others). 2. Orphan issues (based on existing proposals put before the WGEC and the recommendations of the Correspondence Group).

Andrew



Andrew at gp-digital.org



Submission on the first high level principle dealing with free expression, privacy etc. > asserting ICCPR standards on free expression.

Submission on reforming internet governance that keep the dispersed structure and multi-stakeholder participation (which is likely to include ideas on internationalising ICANN and strengthening the IGF)

Matthew

mshears at cdt.org



x

 x

Nnenna

nnenna at webfoundation.org

x





Claudio

claudio at derechosdigitales.org



x - contribute, not lead



Valeria/ APC

valeriab at apc.org



x - contribute

x - contribute

Marianne/ IRP

m.i.franklin at gold.ac.uk



x

 x

Jeanette

hofmann at internetundgesellschaft.de





x - listen and comment

Anriette APC

anriette at apc.org

x

x

x

Anja

anja at internetdemocracy.in

x



x

Joana

joana at varonferraz.com

x

x

x

Jeremy

jeremy at ciroap.org

x





Michael

gurstein at gmail.com



x

x

Marilia

mariliamaciel at gmail.com





3.1/3.2

Rafik

rafik.dammak at gmail.com



x

x

Joy

joy at apc.org<mailto:joy at apc.org>



x

x

Imran

ias_pk at yahoo.com





x

Ian

ian.peter at ianpeter.com







Chinmayi

chinmayiarun at gmail.com



x

x

Cynthia

wongc at hrw.org



x



Avri

avri at acm.org



x



Adam

ajp at glocom.ac.jp



x

x

Pranesh

pranesh at cis-india.org



x

x

Carolina

carolina.rossini at gmail.com

x

x

x

Borami

squ24n at gmail.com



x



Sarah

Sarah.Clarke at pen-international.org



x



Misha

mishi at softwarefreedom.org



x



Deborah/Access

deborah at accessnow.org



x

x

Poncelet

pileleji at ymca.gm

x



x

Lorena

lorena at collaboratory.de



x



Sana

sana at bolobhi.org



x



Jean-Christophe

jc.nothias at theglobaljournal.net



x

x

Bertrand

bdelachapelle at gmail.com





x

Laura

lmottaz at INTERNEWS.ORG

x

x



Parminder

parminder at itforchange.net

x

x

x

Burcu

bkilic at citizen.org

x

x



Matthias will offer international legal expertise on all issues

matthias.kettemann at gmail.com

x

x

x














Andrew Puddephatt | GLOBAL PARTNERS DIGITAL
Executive Director
Development House, 56-64 Leonard Street, London EC2A 4LT
T: +44 (0)20 7549 0336 | M: +44 (0)771 339 9597 | Skype: andrewpuddephatt
gp-digital.org

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.igcaucus.org/pipermail/bestbits/attachments/20131213/17acabdc/attachment.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: Survey monkey download.docx
Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document
Size: 62832 bytes
Desc: Survey monkey download.docx
URL: <http://lists.igcaucus.org/pipermail/bestbits/attachments/20131213/17acabdc/attachment.docx>