[Governance] Fwd: ICANN's decision on proposed PIR transaction

Fri May 1 07:12:19 EDT 2020

This is done!

And I am wondering whether we could discuss lessons learned and anything we
would have done better to not be hurt much by this situation.

All in all, this was a learning experience for all of us, the Internet
global community.

Long live to .org!

---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Andrew Sullivan, Internet Society <mailer at isoc.org>
Date: Fri, May 1, 2020, 12:55 PM
Subject: ICANN's decision on proposed PIR transaction
To: Arsene Tungali <arsenebaguma at gmail.com>

Having trouble viewing this email? Click here
<http://portal.internetsociety.org/622619/bulletin/ViewSent/63b3d79f-c010-4b58-afa0-cedcd9dbde5f/d4d0c1e5-5dc6-4781-8cff-cece8a791032?mid=7b8439c9-7758-44b5-b69f-d78e105f6874&type=e>
to view it online.

[image: Internet Society]
Dear Arsene,

Over the past several months there has been much discussion and interest
within our community regarding the Internet Society’s plan to sell Public
Interest Registry (PIR), operator of .ORG and other top-level domains, to
Ethos Capital. Under PIR’s registry operator agreements, the Internet
Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) must consent to this (or
any other) indirect change of control in order for the transaction to move
to the next phase of the approval process.

ICANN has announced
<https://www.icann.org/news/blog/icann-board-withholds-consent-for-a-change-of-control-of-the-public-interest-registry-pir>
that it does not consent to the transaction. ICANN’s decision effectively
means that the transaction cannot, and will not, proceed.

I am, of course, disappointed by ICANN’s decision. ICANN took much longer
than it should have to render its decision, and in my view, stretched
beyond its own agreements and the remit in its bylaws. I am also concerned
that ICANN has shown itself to be much more susceptible to political
pressure than its mandate would recommend. Nevertheless, I am grateful that
ICANN has now rendered a clear decision. This decision means that the
period of uncertainty is over. In the future, we will continue to rely on
our colleagues at PIR to provide exemplary registries in rigorous
compliance with their ICANN agreements, and to continue to provide generous
funding to the Internet Society.

When the Internet Society Trustees accepted the offer from Ethos in a
unanimous vote, they did so because they believed, and still do, that the
transaction would be good for the Internet Society, good for PIR, and good
for registrants in .ORG and all the registries PIR operates. It’s not very
often where an opportunity presents itself that has advantages for everyone.

When we announced the proposed transaction, several people, including some
in our own community, expressed unhappiness with it. I want to acknowledge
the criticism and emotions that greeted the transaction. I know there are
members of the Internet Society who were angry and hurt by this proposal,
and I am sorry about that.

Several people also expressed disappointment about how the sale was
handled. If we could have better apprised you, our community, in advance of
this sale, we would have. Requests for large-scale consultation came from
across our community; this was not something we could possibly undertake.
The months since the proposal was announced have been hard on PIR’s staff,
and an extended consultation without any clear picture of what the possible
outcomes might be would have been worse for PIR and therefore for .ORG.
Neither the Trustees nor I believed we could undertake such a consultation
without damaging PIR, which would itself be harmful to the community that
relies on .ORG.

Our community has been through a trial, and to address it, the Board of
Trustees has already embarked on efforts to repair our bonds. While there
were differing views about aspects of the proposed transfer, we have a
unity forged in our shared commitment to the Internet, and our collective
will to build a stronger and more accessible Internet is as assured as ever.

The organization has continued to develop its staff function to better
respond to community needs, and to make sure that our work is both
demonstrably useful to the Internet and relevant to its needs. We have
received positive feedback about both the report of our 2019 activities and
the Action Plan for 2020. Our work on encryption, protocols, global
routing, time security, community networks, and other priorities are moving
with pace. Together we have work to do, especially at this time of global
crisis when reliance on communication – and especially the Internet - is
critical for society.

We will continue to grow the operations of the Internet Society Foundation,
and we will keep working with our partners at PIR to ensure that the
Internet Society can continue to build, promote and defend the Internet. In
no way will this disrupt or slow the work of the Internet Society, our
chapters or members, to achieve our vision of an Internet for everyone.

Regards,
Andrew Sullivan
President & CEO, Internet Society
[image: Internet Society]
Don't miss a thing.
Twitter <https://twitter.com/internetsociety> | Facebook
<https://www.facebook.com/InternetSociety> | LinkedIn
<https://ca.linkedin.com/company/internet-society> | YouTube
<https://www.youtube.com/user/InternetSocietyVideo> | Instagram
<https://www.instagram.com/internetsociety/>

This message was sent to Arsene Tungali by the Internet Society.
Please add us to your safe list to ensure delivery.
Unsubscribe
<http://portal.internetsociety.org/622619/Email/Unsubscribe?Eid=7b8439c9-7758-44b5-b69f-d78e105f6874>
| Unsubscribe via email <globalmembership at isoc.org> | Update your
preferences
<http://portal.internetsociety.org/622619/emailpreferences/edit?EntityId=7b8439c9-7758-44b5-b69f-d78e105f6874>
| View Online
<http://portal.internetsociety.org/622619/bulletin/ViewSent/63b3d79f-c010-4b58-afa0-cedcd9dbde5f/d4d0c1e5-5dc6-4781-8cff-cece8a791032?mid=7b8439c9-7758-44b5-b69f-d78e105f6874&type=e>
| Privacy Policy <https://www.internetsociety.org/privacy-policy/> | Contact
Us <https://www.internetsociety.org/contact-us/>
© Copyright 2020 Internet Society
11710 Plaza America Drive, Suite 400, Reston, VA 20190-5108, USA, +1
703-439-2120
Rue Vallin 2, CH-1201, Geneva, Switzerland, +41-22-807-1444
Have questions? Contact globalmembership at isoc.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.igcaucus.org/pipermail/governance/attachments/20200501/c295eb00/attachment.htm>