[bestbits] Re: [governance] Breaking my silence on Netmundial related concerns raised by colleagues from India
Sivasubramanian M
isolatedn at gmail.com
Fri Apr 18 17:10:40 EDT 2014
+1
On Fri, Apr 18, 2014 at 9:18 AM, Ian Peter <ian.peter at ianpeter.com> wrote:
> Subi,
>
> It would have taken a lot of courage to write that, and to engage here. I
> am very glad you did,and thank you for doing so, because it will help to
> eventually clear the air.
>
> My first wish is that, whatever the reactions are to your post, you will
> continue to engage here with the rest of civil society interested in
> internet governance. It’s not always a friendly space, as others have
> discovered, but the interchange and dialogue among people with different
> perspectives here is important, and leads to more constructive and
> valuable inputs for civil society as a whole. Whatever the reactions to
> your post are, I hope you continue to engage here.
>
> My second wish is that everyone involved in this dispute can find a way to
> move past these issues. That’s not going to be easy, and perhaps not
> immediate, but it is important we do so.
>
> My third and final wish is that my first and second wishes come to
> fruition!
>
> Ian Peter
>
>
>
> *From:* Subi Chaturvedi <subi.igp at gmail.com>
> *Sent:* Friday, April 18, 2014 7:56 AM
> *To:* governance at lists.igcaucus.org
> *Cc:* bestbits at lists.bestbits.net
> *Subject:* [governance] Breaking my silence on Netmundial related
> concerns raised by colleagues from India
>
>
> Dear CS colleagues and friends,
>
>
> This has reference to the article published in HT on 8th April, 2014
> which has been shared and referred to on this mailing list, multiple times.
>
> At the outset I want to thank all of you who have written to me showing
> solidarity against this vicious personal attack, based on wrong,
> misleading and manipulated information, indicative of a perverse mind, as
> you'd realize after, going through this post.
>
> I had chosen to maintain silence in the face of repeated and grave
> provocation but the attacks continue unabated, thwarting and disrupting all
> attempts at having any civilized conversation about the key issues that
> concern global CS, even on the eve of Netmundial. The reason why we've
> invested our energy, faith and considerable amount of time engaging with
> the process, in the first place.
>
> I am now also compelled to write this email, for it is unfair on those who
> have shown solidarity with me by writing to me or defending me publicly on
> this list and elsewhere, to be left in this position without a minimal
> comment from me. I wish to assure global civil society that our views are
> being shared, represented and recognised. I have made multiple
> interventions on the calls as well as over emails and continue to work
> across time zones to ensure that our views are reflected. Anriette, my
> colleague from the MAG, has done a fairly balanced assessment of the
> situation though, and I completely agree with her, we have real challenges
> ahead of us. I think our time would be utilised better if we focus on the
> issues at hand- in Netmundial, I see a significant oppurtunity for change.
>
> In the internet, I see not just a source of knowledge but also an
> amplifier of dissent and an enabler of human rights and permissionless
> innovation. I have been a free speech activist and have fought for these
> issues long and hard and therefore this is deeply painful. My interventions
> are available publicly and a basic name search would reveal my
> interventions at the global IGF as well on national media in India. Many of
> these national meetings have been with my friends and respected colleagues
> from civil society in India and remain on their websites or any outreach
> platforms of communication. At the last India IGF MAG meeting where three
> of the co-signatories, who are also on the MAG, made interventions with me.
> Their interventions and mine captured are in the official minutes. In the
> same meeting I was also appointed as the convenor of the Working group of
> the India IGF with the knowledge and consent of Mr.Parmindar from ITfC and
> with consensus from the floor.
>
> My work in the Internet Governance Space and related areas of media and
> communication, deepening democracy and public policy can be found on my
> blog *http://subichaturvedi.blogspot.in/
> <http://subichaturvedi.blogspot.in/>*
>
> Now I ask all of you, who have been relentlessly subjected to the said
> article and appeals by my respectable colleagues and collaborators from
> Indian CS- was it appropriate to include me in this story related to
> surveillance by a corporate? Is there any connection at all? Other than
> to cause harm to me; in which they miserably failed. As identified in
> Ian’s email, apart from being a vicious personal attack, the article is
> manipulative on multiple levels and makes several inaccurate assertions.
>
> Notwithstanding this unfortunate exception, I want to assure all of you
> that journalism in India is free, fair for the most part, and a harbinger
> of truth and justice. I would urge you not to judge Indian media based on
> this article.
>
> I submit the following for your consideration: the portions in italics
> are direct quotes from the same article.
>
> .
>
> a. *“**Emails accessed by HT suggest that Bhatia championed
> Chaturvedi's rise in Indian internet governance circles” .*
>
> You would surely notice that while pdfs of all charges were hyperlinked, this
> allegation conspicuously remains unsubstantiated and any proof to the
> effect is missing from the story. I challenge anyone to put out any
> evidence of anyone- either me or anyone, at all doing any advocacy for me
> to be appointed as the co-chair of Netmundial or on the MAG. It is quite
> unfortunate that my work and my merit should be called into question.
> Undermining all multistakeholder processes. However malicious even the
> article does not make this extrapolation that Mr. Parminder Jeet singh
> repeatedly continues to make. Despite a clarification on the 4th of
> April, 2014 issued by the distinguished academician and General Chair of
> the Meeting Minister Virgilio Almeida.
>
>
>
> b. “*Chaturvedi has also publicly acknowledged a former AT&T official,
> Marylin Cade as a "coach and mentor”:*
>
>
>
> I quote the same tweet: “frm (from) Ms. Marilyn Cade *coach and Mentor
> other proposals* and IGF should limit it’s own”.
>
> [image: Inline images 1]
>
> In plain violation of the most basic tenets of journalism concocting
> evidence, he disingenuously parades my tweet about Ms. Cade’s comment at
> the UN MAG to “coach and mentor other proposals and limit proposals from
> the MAG itself” as my “public acknowledgement” of Ms. Cade being my “coach
> and mentor”.
>
> c. “*She was also paid upwards of **Rs.* *2.3 lakh for her role at a
> FICCI-led conference on internet governance. Subsequently, she also
> received part-funding from FICCI to attend an international conference.
> This raises a clear conflict of interest since she was on board as a civil
> society representative, but accepted payments from industry and corporate
> bodies”.*
>
> He knowingly suppressed the context of the Rs.2.3 lakh (3,814 USD),
> payment by the industry association and presented it as “conflict of
> interest”. The journalist knew fully well that the payment was a
> reimbursement of costs incurred at the request of the conference
> secretariat to produce professional videos, hire resources, material and
> camera costs, still photography, new media activation and related hardware
> and studio costs. He knew but purposefully left out my extensive
> contribution to the conference as a speaker and session organizer on a pro
> bono basis. He deliberately misrepresented in spite of knowing that the
> travel assistance given by the industry association was contributed by ISOC
> (Internet Society) and remaining by NIXI (National Internet Exchange of
> India). He already knew but hid that both organisations routinely provide
> travel assistance to scores of civil society representatives, including to
> some who authored the said letter.
>
>
> This CANNOT under any circumstances be construed as accepting money for
> advocacy from a corporate and presented as "conflict of interest". This
> is the most absurd allegation which even seasoned propagandists would shy
> away from.
>
> Further he deceitfully persisted with the false “conflict of interest”,
> charge by suppressing scores of emails , tweets, posts, videos, film and
> TV interviews given to him and easily available in the public domain, as my
> firm stance against illegal surveillance, invasion of privacy, and
> violation of freedom of speech and expression and human rights.
>
> d. *Ph.D* :
>
> *Can a **mere research studentship**,** which I am still pursuing**,* *be**
> the basis on which I was appointed at any forum?* It was used only to put
> an unsubstantiated charge of plagiarism for my character assassination. I
> preferred to change my guide then to “say sorry”, to her for the offenseI had not committed and continue with her.
>
> With a view to purposefully mislead the readers, the journalist grossly
> manipulated the facts around my PhD by deliberately obfuscating that I have
> steadfastly refuted “any academic wrong doing”.
>
> *The IIT has never charged me with this offense, no show ca**use has ever**
> been given to me and hence no action has been taken against me,* detailed
> evidence was given to the journalist who chose to deliberately ignore it in
> order to convey a premeditated message. IIT has the highest ethical code
> of conduct and so do I. And my PhD. is well underway.
>
>
>
> *The letter of notable members of civil society.*
>
> The CS letter from India carried the support of 10 individuals +1 author,
> some of whom claim to represent different organisations. I have worked
> with most who are in this space including Parminder, Prabir, Anja Kovacs,
> Chinmayi Arun, Rishab Bailey, Mishi Choudhary, Sunil Abraham; 7 Out of 10.
> Two of remaining 3 have attended a national conference on IG with me where
> Parminder was present through out. It is full of misrepresentation. Their
> claims are absurd that:
>
> *1- They don’t know me*
>
> *2. They haven’t worked with me and I am not active in this space.*
>
> *3. They don’t know how to reach me**.*
>
> *4. And I do not teach IG*
>
> *My Response**:*
>
> Ø *Not only do they know me quite well*
>
> Ø *We have hosted joint events, *
>
> Ø *We have served on organizational bodies together related to IG, *
>
> Ø *We have appeared as panelists together on IG, *
>
> Ø *We have traveled and worked together on IG, *
>
> Ø *We have submitted joint inputs to government of India on IG, *
>
> Ø *Prepared background papers together for multistakeholder dialogues
> and events on IG, *
>
> Ø *Co-moderated dialogues and multistakeholder panels on IG. *
>
> Ø *I receive emails from them, respond to them, they have appreciated
> and thanked me for my inputs and efforts. *
>
> Ø *They have called me on my mobile phone *
>
> Ø *They have visited me in person and with their teams to seek my inputs
> on their drafts. *
>
> I am happy to compare and contrast my interventions and my work in the IG
> space with all of them individually or collectively.
>
>
> The ITRs submission of CS was jointly made by
>
> Ø Society for Knowledge commons represented by Rishab Bailey (author of
> the CS letter),
>
> Ø Internet Democracy Project (Anja Kovacs- co-signatory),
>
> Ø Free Software Movement of India (Kiran Chandra (General Secretary-
> co-signatory),
>
> Ø Delhi Science Forum (Prabir – co-signatory),
>
> Ø Media For Change( represented by me)
>
> Ø SFLC.in (Mishi – co-signatory).
>
> Ø Ms. Chinmayi Arun was part of all the 4 day meetings and discussions
> and is on all the emails but did not finally submit the ITRs formal
> response.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> More evidence of Joint work (There’s a lot but I do not wish to burden
> this list)-
>
> One of the recent multistakeholder meeting on IG that I co-organized
> including drafting the background paper with Ms. Anja Kovacs from the
> Internet democracy project (yes we have worked together and collaborated on
> many occasions and often take same positions publicly), was on the 29thJanuary, 2014.
>
>
>
> Where I worked with
>
>
>
> 1. Anja Kovacs, IDP (co-signatory)
>
> 2. Sunil Abraham , CIS (cosignatory)- represented by Snehashish Ghosh
>
> 3. Mishi Chowdhary, SFLC.in (Cosignatory)- represented by Prashanth
> Sugathan
>
> 4. Ms. Chinmayi Arun Co-moderated the meeting with me and Ms. Anja Kovacs
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> *Interlinkages between all the authors of the India CS letter:*
>
>
>
> Ms Anja Kovacs, IDP is a cosignatory & a CIS fellow and has also worked
> for ITfC which is represented on this letter by Mr. Parminder Jeet Singh, Ms.
> Chinmayi Arun from CCG (is a cosignatory & also a CIS fellow), Mr. Sunil
> Abraham is the director of CIS, Rishab Bailey the author of the CS
> letter has been associated with IDP, and with SFLC (another co-signatory)
> and is now representing SKC which is currently represented on this letter by
> Mr. Prabir Purkayastha (co-signatory) who is also associated formally as
> an office bearer with the SFM represented on the letter by Mr. Kiran
> Chandra (co-signatory). All these are respected colleagues and have worked
> with me on the ITRs and many other IG related workshops and panels as
> mentioned above.
>
>
>
> CIS’s director Mr. Sunil Abraham has also served with me on multiple
> panels and bodies together and my interventions can be found online and at
> the CIS website
>
> http://cis-india.org/@@search?SearchableText=subi+chaturvedi
>
>
> They are all signatories to the letter.
>
>
>
> *Again, my heartfelt gratitude to all those who have written to me, or
> supported me. We have a very important task at hand, thank you again for
> reposing your faith and for believing in me. And I wish that at all times
> the dignity of the caucus be preserved and upheld. *
>
>
> Finally, I do not hold any grudges against those, including the journalist
> who may have been involved in this unfortunate and unwarranted personal
> attack. I continue to have the highest respect for the work that my
> colleagues do.
>
>
> I am look forward to working with all of you and will be available in Sao
> Paulo from the 21st and over email. Do feel free to reach out with any
> questions or comments you may have. I would be happy to participate in any
> meeting or related discussion and will continue to work to the best of my
> ability and do my utmost, towards the evolution of the IG ecosphere so that
> we have an internet, which remains free and open, which amplifies human
> rights and allows for permissionless innovation and connects the
> unconnected.
>
>
> More details about my IG interventions can be found on my blog here
> http://subichaturvedi.blogspot.in/
>
>
> and *Contributions at the UN IGF : (Partial List) is available here for
> ready reference*
>
>
> https://www.google.co.in/search?q=igf+MAG+Subi+Chaturvedi+site:www.intgovforum.org&es_sm=91
>
> I am equally thrilled that our collective inputs and suggestions are being
> taken on board. And I am also hopeful that the outcome document will
> reflect truly, what will emerge from the floor. Our friends in Brazil from
> the civil society and from across stakeholder groups have also done
> commendable work to bring us here. Delighted that it will be a
> multistakeholder panel, which will open Netmundial 2014 in Brazil.
>
> Many congratulations Nnenna, we are in great hands. Very proud to have you
> representing us and your address at the IGF 2013, in Bali was both
> profoundly evocative and stirring. I hope you will make time to emphasize
> the role that the Internet is playing especially in peace building and
> conflict transformation as well. Your tremendous and deeply inspiring work
> in Côte d'Ivoire underscores the importance of national and regional
> initiatives, along with intercessional work. We have a fantastic ambassador
> in you. And it might be an uphill climb for all of us but let's put our
> best foot forward.
>
> Looking forward to seeing you all in Sao Paulo soon.
>
> Safe travels, all.
>
>
> Warmest,
>
> Subi
> ----
>
> Subi Chaturvedi
>
> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm,
>
> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR),
>
> Delhi University, India
>
> Twitter:@subichaturvedi
>
> http://subichaturvedi.blogspot.in/
>
>
> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society)
> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society)
> Convenor WG-India IGF
> Co-Chair, Netmundial (Civil Society)
>
>
> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee,
>
> Media For Change
>
>
> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor
>
> The Saltlist
>
> www.thesaltlist.org
>
>
> Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer,
>
> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar
>
>
> PhD. Scholar,
>
> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi
>
>
>
> PS:
>
>
> Global CS Community who may not aware of my contribution here’s snapshot
> ABOUT me and my work specifically on internet /governances/ freedom of
> speech and expression:
>
>
> *IG specific Roles:*
>
>
>
> 1. Recipient of the NIXI (National Internet Exchange, India)
> fellowship for IG 2014-2015
>
> 2. Co-Chair Netmundial 2014
>
> 3. Convenor Working group Indian IGF MAG
>
> 4. Member MAG UN IGF 2014
>
> 5. Member MAG India IGF 2013
>
> 6. Member MAG UN-IGF 2013
>
> 7. Co-Lead Breakout group- Multistakeholderism & Enhance cooperation
> IGF 2013
>
> 8. Lead facilitator main focus session on principles of
> Multistakeholderism IGF 2013
>
> 9. Member MAG IIGC 2013
>
> 10. Member MAG, IIGC 2012
>
> *Made several noteworthy contributions to the IGF and other global and
> national Internet governance processes and capacity building initiatives on
> information and communication especially for under-represented stakeholder
> groups in IG.*
>
>
> I’d be happy to provide detailed reports of my interventions and my
> contributions at each meeting attended or organised National or global.
>
>
>
> https://www.google.co.in/search?q=igf+MAG+Subi+Chaturvedi+site:www.intgovforum.org&es_sm=91#q=igf+MAG+Subi+Chaturvedi+site%3Awww.intgovforum.org&start=0
>
>
> I have been teaching Journalism and Mass Communication including but not
> limited to papers on New Media technology (including IG) and Media, Law and
> Ethics, since the last 5 ½ years in the capcity of Assistant Professor at
> India’s leading liberal arts college for Women, part of Delhi University.
>
> I hold 3 gold medals in Anthropology, Psychology, and a gold medal in
> mass communication from the AJK MCRC, Jamia Millia Islamia, cleared the NET (which
> is a mandatory requirement for teaching at central universities in India), while
> a final year student in my first attempt and then hold a CGPA of 9.25/10 at
> the IIT-D as a part time registered PhD student doing my course work
> without leave from LSR, while taking full classes and contributing to the
> College immensely.
>
> My most recent article was published in the Hindu which is one of India’s
> most respected news daily as the lead opinion commentary on the 18th of
> February- “for an unfettered internet”, and can be accessed here
>
>
> http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/for-an-unfettered-internet/article5699615.ece
>
> It calls for a review of the Indian government’s position on IG.
>
> An article for EPW (a prestigious journal) against Corporatisation of
> Media in India and the loss of pluraity which I have co-authored and the
> documentary film- Freedom Song on issues of Freedom of Speech and
> expression in India for PSBT, co directed with Mr. Paranjoy Guha Thakurta(an eminent journalist from India)
> .
>
> http://www.epw.in/commentary/corporatisation-media.html
>
> The position that I often take is against corporatization and control of
> the media including the Internet by a few, be they governments, private
> sector including large small/corporate of any national origin, civil
> society group All my interventions, which are quite a few and substantive
> in their depth and coverage of issues are online on the IGF website.
>
> *This is just a partial list of some of the work that I have done in this
> academic year 2013-2014:*
>
> My article *“For an unfettered internet’, *was published as the lead
> opinion commentary in The Hindu, India's most respected news daily on why
> India needs to re-examine it's position on global Internet governance.
>
> *http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-opinion/for-an-unfettered-internet/article5700871.ece
> <http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-opinion/for-an-unfettered-internet/article5700871.ece>*
>
> My co-directed critically acclaimed documentary FREEDOM SONG, a film on
> freedom of Speech and expression in contemporary India for PSBT was
> screened at the IIHS Bangalore City Campus this year and premiered at the
> prestigious Open Frame. Two of my curated projects, The Many Moods and
> Moments of Aung San Suu Kyi and ‘The Nobel Women for Peace Project’, were
> exhibited as part of HH. The Dalai Lama’s visit at LSR.
>
>
> In recognition of *my **contribution to Internet and society**,* I been
> awarded:
>
> 1) The prestigious NIXI (National Internet Exchange of India, GOI),
>
> Fellowship for Internet Governance 2013-2014.
>
> 2) I have been appointed as the first Indian woman from two
> stakeholdergroups ( civil society and media) on the United Nations –IGF
> MAG, for the second consecutive term.
>
> 3) I have also been invited to Co-Chair the Global Multistakeholder
> Meeting in Brazil on the Future of the Internet.
>
> 4) I have also been appointed as the convener of the working group of
> the India Internet Governance Forum (IGF) by the Chair from DeitY, Ministry
> of Communication & IT. And also been appointed on the MAG (Multistakeholder
> Advisory Group) of the India IGF (Internet Governance Forum) to be hosted
> by MOC&IT, India.
>
> 5) At the last Global IGF 2013, held at Bali, Indonesia. I contributed
> on several panels on Access and diversity, Relating national and regional
> IGFs, Broadband access and local content, emerging issues- Surveillance and
> a enhance cooperation (I also the remote moderator for it). And I also
> moderated and mentored DoT (MoC&IT), Government of India’s Open forum
> “Connecting the next Billion”. Additionally I also organized and spoke at
> the Main Focus session on Multistakeholderism as a panelist.
>
> 6) I also co-organised a multistakeholder panel discussion on “Will
> Internet and Social Media be a game changer for the next general election
> 2014 with senior leaders and ministers from the government and eminent
> journalists and editors at the India International Centre (IIC), New Delhi.
>
> 7) I was also a panelist with sr. editors on the role of media in
> promoting art at the global stage organized by exchange4media at IIC.
>
> 8) I was also a panelist at the National Convention on "Crisis of
> Capitalism and brazen onslaught on DEMOCRACY" , organized by the INSAF
> foundation at the constitution club for the session on SURVEILLANCE, STATE
> AND PERILS OF DEMOCRACY. With Mr. Prabir who is a cosignatory of the
> letter.
>
> 9) I was a panelist on IGF and the way forward organized by ORF, New
> Delhi. Ms. Anja Kovacs was my co-panelist a basic online search would
> reveal and expose the claims made in the letter. The ORF report is online
> with our interventions and images together.
>
> 10) I was also the key note speaker on Internet –a
> democratic space, at NALSAR along with eminent and sr. judges and lawyers
> of the supreme court on Social Media and Hate speech. Both Ms. Chinmayi
> Arun and Ms. Anja Kovacs were part of the same event. Ms. Kovacs was,moreover on the same session as I was.
>
> 11) I also organized and moderated a multitsakeholder
> panel discussion at the ITU-WSIS 2013, Geneva on, “ Ensuring Internet
> Access and Better Governance by Deepening Multistakeholderism- A Developing
> Nation Perspective with sr. ministers and heads of regional and national
> Internet & ICT initiatives.
>
> 12) Held a capacity building Workshop for the youth
> -"Towards a new Ethics of Cyberspace- Being a responsible online Digital
> Citizen with sr. industry leaders as key resource persons.
>
> 13) I also appeared as a distinguished panelist on
> national media on internet, new media regulation and social media, women
> safety and empowerment related issues, through the year.
>
> 14) I also organised and moderated the MEDIA CONGRESS-
> Panel on 'Government Surveillance vs Individual Privacy : Are they mutually
> exclusive?' with distinguished speakers: Dr. Usha Rmanathan eminent civil
> society activist, Dr. Govind, CEO NIXI, Mr. Pavan Duggal, Prof. Vibodh
> Parthasarathi and Ms. Shalini Singh.
>
> 15) I was also a panelist at the IMDEC 2013, Panel on
> “The Internet We Want: A Multistakeholder View” along with global leaders
> from civil society, industry, government and the technical community at
> FICCI. Mr. Sunil Abraham (CIS) was also an invited panelist.
>
> 16) I co-organised a multistakeholder dialogue on *The
> Future of the Internet, who should govern it & what is at stake for us*with sr. members of the government, industry, academia, technical
> community, media at IIC. The youth were also invited as end users to share
> their inputs and experiences. The background paper was jointly prepared
> by me and Ms. Anja Kovacs.
>
> 17) I also organized a youth meet with over 700 youth
> leaders from India on the Internet We Want- Conversation Series.
>
> 18) Another youth meet was organized by me at the Aligarh
> Muslim University, a minority institution with over 300 youth delegates
> from the minorities and the margins and sr. editors from the media on the
> role of media and youth in election 2014 particularly the impact that
> social media and the internet can have in amplyfying participation of the
> youth.
>
> 19) I was also invited to conduct a leadership training
> workshop for the sr. management of TATA Sons and their group companies on
> social media.
>
> 20) I also conducted a third youth meet over 700 young
> leaders on the “Digital Agenda for the Youth and IG principals”. This was
> part of the global #FightBack campaign against surveillance and held on the
> world internet day.
>
> 21) I was also a invited to present my paper on
> Cybersecurity a multistakeholder perspective by ORF New Delhi part of the
> young voices policy forum. It was extremely well received.
>
> 22) I also led the new media outreach and supported the
> on ground activation for the national Internet Safety campaign for the
> youth in India in association with Data Security Council of India (A
> NASSCOM initiative).
>
> 23) I am a member of the International Association for
> Women in Radio and television (IAWRT) and the Internet Society (ISOC).
>
>
>
> warmest
>
> Subi
> ----
>
> Subi Chaturvedi
>
> Assistant Prof. Journalism & Comm,
>
> Lady Shri Ram College for Women (LSR),
>
> Delhi University, India
>
> Twitter:@subichaturvedi
>
> http://subichaturvedi.blogspot.in/
>
>
> Member MAG, UN-IGF (Media & Civil Society)
>
> Member MAG, India-IGF (Civil Society)
>
> Convenor WG-India IGF
>
> Co-Chair, Netmundial (Civil Society)
>
>
> Founder & Hon. Managing Trustee,
>
> Media For Change
>
>
> Founder, Chief Mentor & Editor
>
> The Saltlist
>
> www.thesaltlist.org
>
>
> Independent DocumentaryFilmmaker, Photographer,
>
> Curator, Media Critic & Scholar
>
>
> PhD. Scholar,
>
> Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-D), New Delhi
>
> ------------------------------
> ____________________________________________________________
> You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
> governance at lists.igcaucus.org
> To be removed from the list, visit:
> http://www.igcaucus.org/unsubscribing
>
> For all other list information and functions, see:
> http://lists.igcaucus.org/info/governance
> To edit your profile and to find the IGC's charter, see:
> http://www.igcaucus.org/
>
> Translate this email: http://translate.google.com/translate_t
>
>
> ____________________________________________________________
> You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
> bestbits at lists.bestbits.net.
> To unsubscribe or change your settings, visit:
> http://lists.bestbits.net/wws/info/bestbits
>
--
Sivasubramanian Muthusamy
India +91 99524 03099
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.igcaucus.org/pipermail/governance/attachments/20140419/36d3492b/attachment.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: tweet.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 84909 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.igcaucus.org/pipermail/governance/attachments/20140419/36d3492b/attachment.jpg>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: My org in a Jt. submission on ITR by Indian CS co-signatories where the author of the Indian CS letter against me represents me.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 593712 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.igcaucus.org/pipermail/governance/attachments/20140419/36d3492b/attachment-0001.jpg>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: MS Dialogue on Internet Governance e-invite.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 134414 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.igcaucus.org/pipermail/governance/attachments/20140419/36d3492b/attachment-0002.jpg>
-------------- next part --------------
____________________________________________________________
You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
governance at lists.igcaucus.org
To be removed from the list, visit:
http://www.igcaucus.org/unsubscribing
For all other list information and functions, see:
http://lists.igcaucus.org/info/governance
To edit your profile and to find the IGC's charter, see:
http://www.igcaucus.org/
Translate this email: http://translate.google.com/translate_t
More information about the Governance
mailing list