[governance] Internet access is 'a fundamental right'

Jean-Louis FULLSACK jlfullsack at orange.fr
Mon Mar 8 16:18:01 EST 2010

Dear Parminder 

Please don't tell it to our colleagues : I'm still not much convinced that Internet access is actually "a fundamental right". What I'm quite sure : it isn't an "essential (ethymologically speaking) right". Even ICTs aren't ! That was well proven by the five thematic domains the UN Secretary General assigned to the the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Jo'burg through the acronym WEHAB : Water, Energy,Health, Agriculture and Biodiversity. There isn't the least allusion to ICT ! Only the WSIS carried this tall story of ICT saving the world from any evil ! 

Listening to the daily news and watching regularly reports from Africa rather strengthen my scepticism about this legend. Let's be realistic and let's try to do our best for making the ICTs the most effective tool for education, for poverty alleviation and for human and economic development. Without no doubt, Internet will have all its place in that struggle, even without "fundamental rights" !

Fiendliest yours 

Jean-Louis Fullsack

> Message du 08/03/10 17:51
> De : "Parminder" 
> A : governance at lists.cpsr.org
> Copie à : 
> Objet : [governance] Internet access is 'a fundamental right'
For the rights skeptics, if they believe in people's verdict :)
(also enclosed full report )
Internet access is 'a fundamental right' 
Almost four in five people around the world believe that access to the internet is a fundamental right, a poll for the BBC World Service suggests.
> The survey - of more than 27,000 adults across 26 countries - found strong support for net access on both sides of the digital divide. 
> Countries such as Finland and Estonia have already ruled that access is a human right for their citizens. 
> International bodies such as the UN are also pushing for universal net access. 
The right to communicate cannot be ignored," Dr Hamadoun Toure, secretary-general of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), told BBC News. 
> "The internet is the most powerful potential source of enlightenment ever created." 
> He said that governments must "regard the internet as basic infrastructure - just like roads, waste and water". 
> "We have entered the knowledge society and everyone must have access to participate."
> The survey, conducted by GlobeScan for the BBC, also revealed divisions on the question of government oversight of some aspects of the net. 
> Web users questioned in South Korea and Nigeria felt strongly that governments should never be involved in regulation of the internet. However, a majority of those in China and the many European countries disagreed. 
> In the UK, for example, 55% believed that there was a case for some government regulation of the internet. 
> Rural retreat
> The finding comes as the UK government tries to push through its controversial Digital Economy Bill. 
> As well as promising to deliver universal broadband in the UK by 2012, the bill could also see a so-called "three strikes rule" become law. 
> This rule would give regulators new powers to disconnect or slow down the net connections of persistent illegal file-sharers. Other countries, such as France, are also considering similar laws.
> Recently, the EU adopted an internet freedom provision, stating that any measures taken by member states that may affect citizen's access to or use of the internet "must respect the fundamental rights and freedoms of citizens". 
> In particular, it states that EU citizens are entitled to a "fair and impartial procedure" before any measures can be taken to limit their net access. 
> The EU is also committed to providing universal access to broadband. However, like many areas around the world the region is grappling with how to deliver high-speed net access to rural areas where the market is reluctant to go. 
> Analysts say that is a problem many countries will increasingly have to deal with as citizens demand access to the net. 
> The BBC survey found that 87% of internet users felt internet access should be the "fundamental right of all people". 
> More than 70% of non-users felt that they should have access to the net. 
> Overall, almost 79% of those questioned said they either strongly agreed or somewhat agreed with the description of the internet as a fundamental right - whether they currently had access or not. 
> Free speech
> Countries such as Mexico, Brazil and Turkey most strongly support the idea of net access as a right, the survey found. 
> More than 90% of those surveyed in Turkey, for example, stated that internet access is a fundamental right - more than those in any other European Country.
> South Korea - the most wired country on Earth - had the greatest majority of people (96%) who believed that net access was a fundamental right. Nearly all of the country's citizens already enjoy high-speed net access. 
> The survey also revealed that the internet is rapidly becoming a vital part of many people's lives in a diverse range of nations. 
> In Japan, Mexico and Russia around three-quarters of respondents said they could not cope without it. 
> Most of those questioned also said that they believed the web had a positive impact, with nearly four in five saying it had brought them greater freedom. 
> However, many web users also expressed concerns. The dangers of fraud, the ease of access to violent and explicit content and worries over privacy were the most concerning aspects for those questioned. 
> A majority of users in Japan, South Korea and Germany felt that they could not express their opinions safely online, although in Nigeria, India and Ghana there was much more confidence about speaking out.

> [ 08_03_10_BBC_internet_poll.pdf (657.2 Ko) ]
> [ message-footer.txt (0.4 Ko) ]
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.igcaucus.org/pipermail/governance/attachments/20100308/6be1d5e3/attachment.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
     governance at lists.cpsr.org
To be removed from the list, send any message to:
     governance-unsubscribe at lists.cpsr.org

For all list information and functions, see:

Translate this email: http://translate.google.com/translate_t

More information about the Governance mailing list