[governance] NomCom nomination statments - To publish or not to Publish

[Meryem Marzouki]

Hi all,

I'm confident that all candidates (self) nominated to the nomcom will  
agree on having their info published.

However, if only for a question of principle, I have to say that this  
proposal below is something I cannot even figure out. It's not a good  
start, at least.

I understand that this was not made explicit from the beginning.  
Perhaps because it seemed obvious?
And what about the nomcom, then? It was not made clear that its  
members have to sign a non disclosure agreement before  
volunteering... OK, I trust them, they all are nice people. But it  
was not made clear either that they would have to disregard the fact,  
if ever this happens, that candidates who would like to be  
recommended by the IGC to the IGF have nevertheless chosen to hide  
this, even to IGC members, unless they are eventually chosen. Would  
the publication of information be an additional criteria for the  
nomcom? After all, the nomcom will use its own criteria.

Maybe we should have asked the FBI to put the nomcom members in a  
safe place with no contact with anyone before the start of the  
process...

Next time we should discuss what 'individual privacy' means. And what  
'transparency' means. Among a long list of other issues.

Meryem

Le 12 avr. 06 à 21:53, Avri Doria a écrit :

> Hi,
>
> The few public comments sent to the list seem to indicate a
> preference for publishing names.  Since this was not made clear to
> candidates before the process, I plan to respect individual privacy
> by asking each candidate whether they accept having their information
> published.
>
> The IGC nomcom will therefore publish the names, information and bios/
> statements of nominees according to the following process:
>
> Assuming that they, or their nominator, have not already given
> permission to publish, I send send email to each nominee individually
> asking for permission to publish their information.
>
> - if they agree, their info will be published
> - if the don't agree i will ask for permission to at least list their
> names, nationality and gender.
> - to account for any who don't agree to have their names and basic
> information published, we will include a count of unpublished
> candidates on the web site.
>
> hope this works for the caucus.
>
> thanks
> a.
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> governance mailing list
> governance at lists.cpsr.org
> https://ssl.cpsr.org/mailman/listinfo/governance


_______________________________________________
governance mailing list
governance at lists.cpsr.org
https://ssl.cpsr.org/mailman/listinfo/governance